Don't miss out! Get updates via email.

Homemade Cream-Of Soup Mix

Homemade Cream-Of Soup Mix

Disclosure: Some content includes links to sponsors or affiliates, which give me a small percentage of the sale. You are not obligated to use these links when you make a purchase, but when you do so it helps to support this site, so thank you!

Let’s be honest…there are times when I’m just lazy. I might run out of Homemade Cream of Chicken Soup and be too busy to make more…or too lazy. I try to always keep some in the freezer, but sometimes I run out. I know it’s quick and easy to whip up a batch, but I’ll be honest again. If I see a recipe that calls for it and I know I have to make some because I’m out – I pretty much nix that recipe. Can I get a witness?!

While I just love cooking, and don’t mind making the homemade cream of soup, sometimes I just can’t get around to it…and for those times, there is this lovely stand-in made with dried ingredients. Having this in the cabinet makes me feel like I can conquer any cream-of recipe! It also makes me feel like I need a casserole – casseroles are where it’s at.

Organic milk and cornstarch

Okay, so this recipe uses powdered milk and cornstarch. I know there are really strict hard-core foodies out there who would scream and cry and foam at the mouth because I’m using dried milk…but as we all know, I’m not a strict hard-core foodie.

Yes, I understand that dried milk might not be a “whole food.” But let’s just get something out of the way here – to me, using this mix that I made is 100 times better than using a can of cream-of soup from the store. I know what’s in this…because I made it. The ingredients on the dried milk say: organic skim milk. While I am a firm believer in whole milk, I don’t mind using skim dried milk.

*Note – Dairy Free? Use Rice Milk Powder.*

I do realize that using high quality ingredients is better – so, I went with a non-instant version of dried milk and I opted for the organic. Also, because GMO corn gives me the freak out, I also opted for organic cornstarch. Could you use arrowroot? Probably…but I wanted to use cornstarch. Why? Who knows…just go with it. I easily found these ingredients at Vitacost.

Stir it up, buttercup

This really is super easy. Put all the dry ingredients in a bowl and whisk. Store in an airtight container in the pantry. The only thing you could mess up here is to create a huge cloud of dry milk while mixing too hard. But really…who would do that? *Cough*

Now, here is the tricky part – you have to make it into a soup. For cream-of chicken soup, you’ll mix your powder with chicken broth. For cream-of mushroom soup, you’ll use water and some diced, cooked mushrooms…and for cream-of celery soup, you’ll mix it with water and add some celery seed or diced, cooked celery.  I’ll provide instructions below in the recipe.

Cream-Of Soup Base

Casserole dishes all across America are happy again! They’re going to be pulled out of their dusty cabinet homes and be used for Chicken Spaghetti. It’s a miracle.

This recipe is brought to you by the Stacy Is Freaked Out By GMO Corn Coalition. We accept casserole donations.

Comment Policy: I love hearing your thoughts and input on what I write. Since I write about what works at my house, what pleases my handsome hubby and darling children; I'm sure we'll disagree sometimes. In those cases, do what's right for you and yours. As with any form of communication, please only post comments that move the discussion in a positive direction.

About Stacy

Stacy is the author of Crock On: A Semi-Whole Foods Slow Cooker Cookbook and Keep Crockin': A Poorganic Slow Cooker Cookbook, and a stay-at-home and homeschooling mom to her three children, Annie (June 2009), Andy (August 2012) and Eli (September 2014). After an “awakening” in March 2011, her family switched to a more natural, whole foods diet. She likes to blog about how to live on less than you make and how to eat good food while doing it. Her passion is teaching others how to save money and she tag teams with her husband in this endeavor. At Stacy Makes Cents you’ll find information on how to save money in the kitchen, how to have fun with your kids, and how to be thrifty in all areas of life. Her passion is teaching others how to live debt free. Make sure to follow her on Facebook, Youtube, Pinterest and more to keep up with her daily antics.

  • Amanda

    This is an awesome idea.

    • Stacy

      :-) I think so too!

  • Michaeleen

    You got it girl, excellent points, and a little convience can go a long way in getting a great & healthy dinner on the table fast(er) some days…as a self-professed MAJOR foodie, I approve of this post! Keep up your great work, Stacy.

    • Stacy

      Woot!!! :-)

  • Leslie G

    OK, I haven’t made a casserole calling for cream-of… soup in about 3 years mainly because the canned stuff is really scary. Your recipe sounds awesome. Does it matter if this is not condensed?

    • Stacy

      Sometimes recipes that call for condensed soup also call for liquids, so you just won’t need as much….I just play around with it until I get it the right consistency.

  • Julia

    AWESOME! This is just what I needed. I too have skipped making recipes because I didn’t have the homemade in the freezer and the can kind is one of 3 things I refuse to buy (or eat unless its my only option). Thanks again for keeping it real (and helping keep my sanity in check! )

    • Stacy

      :-) You are most welcome. I have to be real – I don’t have time for fake. LOL

  • Colleen

    I had no idea it was this easy! I’ll be whipping up a batch after I survive the holidays!!

    (And Stacy, as a girl who grew up in Nebraska surrounded by real corn, I say GMO Corn should freak EVERYONE out.)

    • Stacy


  • Cynthia Combest

    Another great idea!!!! Thank you!

    • Stacy

      You’re most welcome! :-)

  • Kate

    Thanks, Stacy – another great idea.

    What makes a dry milk be a “non-instant” milk? I’ve not heard of a powdered milk that is mixed with water being referred to as “non-instant” before.
    (Like, does the milk powder sit in the bottom and refuse to mix with the water until they’ve had time to establish a relationship and get to know each other a bit??)

    • Stacy

      Secretly, I’ve wondered the same thing….however this is labeled as “non-instant.” LOL

  • leslie

    Just a quick note about substituting other things for the cornstarch…I have used this recipe for years and recently
    tweaked it to try to avoid the cornstarch – FAIL!!!! I tried zanthan gum and arrowroot (separately) and it turned out very gummy and unusable. Just thought I’d pass on that the cornstarch really does seem to be the best. And yes, I use organic cornstarch, too. :) Good post, Stacy.

    • Stacy

      That’s a bummer. I’ve always had good luck with arrowroot. Well, shoot a monkey.

  • leslie

    Another recent experiment was more of a success…I was out of the mix, so heated up chicken broth, brought it to a boil, then added milk mixed with cornstarch. It was delicious and worked great in my recipe. I haven’t tried your recipe for cream soup, but maybe it is similar?

    • Stacy

      Yep! Very similar. :-)

  • Bama Girl

    Hi Stacy! Thank you so much for posting this recipe! I will use the ingredients I have on hand, instant dry milk powder and arrowroot. I hope it works just as good! Blessings from Bama!

    • Stacy

      I love arrowroot! :-)

  • Correna

    All I can say is Thank you, thank you, thank you, Oh, and thank you.

    • Stacy

      It’s a Christmas miracle! :-)

  • jade

    Awesome! I’m searching for a dairy free alternative to the milk!? I’d appreciate any insight! And, I too shiver at GMO corn anything :S scary stuff….

    • Stacy

      My friend Erin is looking for the same – if she finds it, I’ll update the recipe. :-)

  • Jo

    Thanks for the info and heres one in return. I adore cream of mushroom soup, so I dehydrate mushrooms and store them in the freezer. Then, just melt some butter, add dehydrated shrooms and whatever herbs you want, saute (or microwave)until you smell wonderful shroomy goodness. Add that to your quick method and everyone will think it took you all day! (also excellent for green bean casserole!) Careful, dehyderated mushrooms tend to have a more concentrated flavor!

    • Stacy

      Great tip, thanks! :-) I got freaked out my mushrooms when I was pregnant with Andy, so I haven’t really had them since then.

  • Erin@TheHumbledHomemaker

    This…is…genius! Now, if I could just find some dairy-free milk powder!

    • Stacy

      Girl, I hope you can find that! And if you do, let me know and I’ll make a note on the recipe. :-)

      • Rosie

        Amazon has rice milk powder. I have not been able to find any in stores around Indianapolis. Have yet to try this recipe but i bought the rice milk powder just for this reason.

        • Stacy

          Yep! Amazon is where I saw it too – I linked it in the post. :-)

      • Tina Larson

        I use non dairy creamer

  • Michelle

    We use this often but I’ve always hated to admit it since it’s not really “real” food. Thanks for making me feel a bit better by admitting you sometimes use it too. :) It does taste so much better than the canned stuff and is so easy for anyone to whip up. I always use it in place of a can of cream of whatever in recipes without making any adjustments and it always turns out fine.

    • Stacy

      That’s what I do too. :-) I usually don’t have time to fiddle with sauteing veggies to throw in it. And comfort yourself with the fact that this is a lot better than cream-of-whoknowswhat. 😉

  • Loni Gofran

    GMO corn freaks us out too, but with my husband being GF, we don’t know where to get, nor can we afford, organic substitutes of all the corn products we buy- we eat a lot of mexican because we live in texas, and because it’s easy to do GF, so we use a lot of corn tortillas, tortilla chips, and the like. I know it’s something we need to change, but we do love our mexican night :( Tips?

    • Stacy

      I wish I had tips. It’s soooooo hard to avoid GMO corn. It’s in everything! We love Mexican food too.

  • Debra

    I used to make this all the time.

    • Stacy

      Because you’re smart….that’s why I like ya. :-)

  • Diana

    Yes, seriously GMO corn is c-r-a-z-y, I don’t care who calls it “safe” (I could call myself a monkey but you’d be one to believe me!) if it splits bugs stomachs open when they eat it I’m not touching it! Phew. Glad to know we have yet one more thing in common Stacy. I really wouldn’t be surprised if we were related.
    This Cream ‘O Soup is a great idea!! Can’t wait to try it… For those wanting to try dairy free versions of “cream of” soup, why not try adding coconut cream and then thickening with a veggie or chicken broth/corn starch mixture? Just make sure that corn starch is organic- this has been a public service announcement by the SADAFOBGCC (StacyandDianaAreFreakedOutByGMOCornCoalition) 😉

    • Stacy

      LOL :-)

  • Sarah

    I am trying this today! Has anyone used instant dried milk? I have looked several places and its all I could ever find.

    • Stacy

      It should work just fine. I found the non-instant on Vitacost. :-)

  • kevin

    your resipe card does not tel people to sub water for chicken broth when making the other soups///may be a nobrainer but some of us need all the help we can get, Also what is the difference brtween non instant and instant? arnt they prepaired the same?
    Thanks Kevin

    • Stacy

      Hi Kevin!
      I’m a bit confused by your comment because when I look at the recipe card, at the bottom I see instructions to make Cream of Chicken, Cream of Mushroom, and Cream of Celery. It’s under the instructions.
      Instant and non-instant are made differently and behave different in cooking. Either would work for this recipe. I just prefer non-instant. Here is a great explanation of the differences – non-instant does better with hot liquids. :-)

  • Heidi

    I LOVE this! I just made this for the second time. Both times I have ended up with a thick layer of burnt schutff (milk??) on the bottom of my pan. Have you had that experience? I’m sure it’s 100% user error, but am just wondering if I need to be constantly stirring it before the boil??

    Both times I was distracted with other parts of the recipe and let it come to a boil while I wasn’t paying attnention so I’m thiking that might be the problem. Both times I was able to use the rest of the mix so it wasn’t a big deal, but was just wondering if I’m the only one who has had that problem

    • Stacy

      I have that same problem when I get distracted and forget to stir regularly. Milk is really weird when it’s heated. :-) So, no worries….Stacy probably does it more than you. lol

  • Jen

    I am so happy to have discovered your blog! Making this today…thank you!

    • Stacy

      You’re welcome! I hope it works out great for ya!

  • Jenny

    I have to avoid gluten and dairy too – wondering – Could you just leave out the dried milk entirely and substitute a non-dairy milk for some of the liquid when reconstituting? I dunno, I use thickened broth w/out dairy all the time – I’m totally trying it. :-) Thanks for the recipe with seasonings – that’s always my great mystery!!

    • Stacy

      Good luck! I hope it works beautifully!

  • Adrienne

    Believe it or not…I am going to try to make this dairy free! Thanks! I think I have a good idea…..

  • Nancy H

    Can’t wait to try this!

    Related question (sorta)…..what’s your stance on Jello as far as whole foods goes? Is there a way to make it without all the sugar & artificial colors or is this just another item to add to my ‘Permanently Given Up for Lent’ List?

    Thanks & God bless!!! :)

    • Stacy

      We don’t eat Jello – for me it’s because I just hate it. LOL For Annie it’s because we avoid food coloring in our home. But you can easily make homemade jello using unflavored gelatin. :-)

  • Stephanie Allen

    I just found your blog. I Love this. I’ll be trying this soon!! Thank you! Just a little FYI…just because its an organic corn product does NOT mean its non-GMO! It has to say non-GMO! I found this out about a year ago, just in case you didn’t know. thanks again, Stephanie

    • Stacy

      Interesting. Thanks!

  • Coreen

    Stacy I was wondering what the GMO stands for?I’ve never used organic cornstarch but if the GMO is really bad i definatly wanna be switching!!!

    • Stacy

      GMOs are Genetically Modified Organisms. It’s pretty scary stuff. You can find out more at The Non-GMO Project. We try to avoid them whenever possible. :-)

  • Kimberly

    I love this recipe and can’t wait to try it. Quick question what kind of lid is that on your jar? Thanks

    • Stacy

      It’s a jar I picked up at a yard sale. I love it. :-) The lid came with it.

  • Darlene in North GA

    About the instant/non-instant milk. I’ve been told by those whom use a lot of powdered milk that if you put instant milk powder in a blender and blend it until it’s more finely “powdered” than it is, you can then use the same measurements as the non-instant milk. It seems that the larger “chunks” of powder cause a difference in the amount you’re using – which is logical as the more finely powdered non-instant is more compact than the larger instant milk powder.

    • Stacy

      Well, who knew? I tried finding that information online, but everything was so vague. Thanks!

  • Darlene in North GA

    And I almost forgot. For those that want/need dairy-free/corn-free, use raw, ground white beans. I swear, you cannot tell that beans were used in it! I run my beans through my wheat grinder, but I’ve also used a coffee mill (one that HASN’T been used for coffee or strong spices!), to grind the raw beans and then, once it’s been cooked, pureed the soup in the blender or with a stick blender to make sure it’s smooth. And it only takes about 5 minutes to make it with the ground beans. In fact, you won’t need anything but raw, ground white beans and either chicken (or whatever flavoring you want)bouillon or broth to make it. So no corn products in it either.

    • Stacy

      Thanks for the tip!

  • Sherry

    I love this idea! generally when a recipe calls for cream of….soup I make a white sauce and add whatever flavour is needed. I made this mix a couple of weeks ago and just used it to make my version of Costco’s Chicken Bake. I made the cream of soup, added a package of reduced fat cream cheese, about 1/2 a rotisserie chicken, and about 2 cups of frozen veggies. I rolled out homemade bread dough and put some of this mixture in it and voila…healthier Chicken Bake for my family of four :)

    • Stacy

      I was trying to read your comment and all I could read was “cream cheese.” Yes…blessed cream cheese. How I love thee. *Slobber*

  • Alex

    Hey Stacy,

    Have you ever tried this recipe to make cream of cheddar soup? I’m guessing that either 1 cup of cheddar or a mixture of cream cheese and cheddar should do it. I’m dying for homemade Mac and cheese over here and my mothers recipe of course calls for cream of cheddar >_<

    • Stacy

      No, I haven’t tried it but I imagine it would work. It’s a good base for most cream-of soups. Or you could check out my Mac and Cheese recipe – no cream soups needed! :-)

  • Sarah

    Ooh – what a useful thing to have! Thanks for the recipe. I’ve pinned it for future reference.

    • Stacy

      Thanks! :-)

  • Annie

    Would these recipes work if it they were prepared and added to freezer meals? I am stocking up the freezer and trying to make healthier versions for after our fourth baby is born soon. Thank you!

    • Stacy

      It should work just fine. :-)